Book 6 Chapter 2

Philosophical Education Icon

September 9, 2015

The Characteristics of Guardians

Adeimantus Adeimantus= Which of the current governments are adapted to philosophy?
Socrates

None of them.

The exotic seed which is sown in a foreign land becomes denaturalized. Similarly, philosophy grown in a bad soil degenerates and receives another character.

But if philosophy ever finds perfection in a State, then she will be seen in truth divine and that all other things, whether natures of men or institutions, are but human.

Adeimantus Are we the founders and inventors of such a State?
Socrates

Yes, in most respects. The question is= How should philosophy be studied as not to be the ruin of the State?

States should pursue philosophy, not as they do now, but in a different spirit.

At present, the students of philosophy are quite young. From after childhood, they devote only the time saved from moneymaking and housekeeping to philosophy.

Even the most philosophical quit philosophy when they encounter the great difficulty of dialectics. When they grow old, they are extinguished and never light up again.

Their course should just be the opposite.

In childhood and youth, their study of philosophy should be suited to their tender years. While they are growing up, the chief care should be given to their bodies that they can be used for philosophy.

As life advances and the intellect begins to mature, let them increase the soul’s gymnastics. But when the strength of our citizens fails and is past civil and military duties, then let them range at will and engage in no serious labour.

Adeimantus How truly in earnest you are, Socrates! Yet most of your hearers are likely to oppose you, especially Thrasymachus.
Socrates

Do not make a quarrel between Thrasymachus and me. He and I have recently become friends, although we were never enemies.

I shall strive to convert him and other men, or do something which may profit them for the day when they reincarnate and hold the like discourse in another life .

Adeimantus That time is far away.
Socrates

But that time is near, relative to eternity.

Many refuse to believe philosophy for they have never seen what we have. They:

  • have seen only a conventional imitation of philosophy, made of words artificially brought together, unlike ours that have a natural unity
  • have never seen any human who is perfectly moulded into virtue in word and deed, ruling in a city which is also virtuous
  • have seldom heard the free and noble feelings which are uttered when they seek truth for the sake of knowledge

These result in opinion and strife in society.

Socrates

This was why truth forced us to admit that neither cities, States, nor individuals will attain perfection until:

  • the small class of useless but non-corrupt philosophers are compelled to take care of the State, and
  • a like necessity is laid on the State to obey them, or
  • kings or princes, are divinely inspired with a true love of true philosophy.

If these alternatives are impossible, then we can be justly ridiculed as dreamers and visionaries.

If the perfected philosopher is compelled by a superior power to take charge of the State, we will assert to the death, that this is because our constitution has Philosophy as its queen.

This is difficult, but not impossibile.

Adeimantus But do you mean that the multitude thinks it as impossible?
Socrates

Do not attack the multitude. They will change their minds if you gently and soothingly, not aggressively:

  • remove their dislike of over-education,
  • show them your philosophers as they really are, and
  • describe their character and profession.

Then, they will see that philosophers are not useless as they supposed.

Who can hate anyone who loves them? Who will be jealous anyone who is not jealous?

Socrates

This harsh temper may be found in a few, but not in the majority of mankind. The harsh feeling that people have towards philosophy comes from the pretenders, who:

  • rush in uninvited,
  • are always abusing them,
  • finding fault with them, and
  • make persons instead of things the theme of their conversation.

Nothing can be more unbecoming in philosophers than this. A person always views fixed and immutable things if his mind:

  • is fixed on true being, and
  • has no time to look down on earthly affairs or have malice and envy against other men
Socrates

He sees neither injuring nor injured by one another, but all in order moving according to reason. These he imitates, and to these he will, as far as he can, conform himself.

A man cannot imitate that with which he holds reverential converse.

The philosopher converses with the divine order becomes orderly and divine. But like every one else, he will suffer from detraction. If he needs to fashion himself and human nature in States or in individuals into the divine, he will be a skillful artificer of justice, temperance, and every civil virtue.

If the world thinks that what we are saying about him is true, will they be angry with philosophy?

Will they disbelieve us when we tell them that no State can be happy which is not designed by artists who imitate the heavenly pattern?

Adeimantus They will not be angry if they understand. But how will they draw out the plan?
Socrates

They will begin by taking the State and the manners of men.

Like a tablet, they will rub out the picture, and leave a clean surface.

This is not easy.

Until the philosophers have found or made a clean surface, they will:

  • have nothing to do with the individual or the State, and
  • will inscribe no laws.
Socrates

They will then:

  • trace an outline of the constitution
  • look at absolute justice and beauty and temperance, and again at the human copy
  • mingle and temper the various elements of life into the image of a man
  • conceive this according to as what Homer calls ’the form and likeness of God'
  • erase and add features until they have made the ways of men agreeable to the ways of God

We shall persuade the people that that is the goal of the painter of constitutions.

At first they were very indignant because we committed the State to the philosopher. Now, they are calmer.

Adeimantus But they will tell us that such a nature will not be perfectly good and wise. They will prefer those whom we have rejected.
Socrates

No. They will be less angry at us saying that until philosophers rule:

  • States and individuals will have no rest from evil, and
  • our ideal State will never be realized.

Some kings or princes are by nature philosophers. There are examples of this in history. This means that it is possible for one man to:

  • have a city obedient to his will, and
  • create the ideal State about which the world is so incredulous.

The ruler may impose the laws and institutions we described.

Adeimantus How and by what studies will the saviours of the constitution be created? When are they to apply themselves to their several studies?
Socrates

I omitted the troublesome business of:

  • the possession of women,
  • the procreation of children,
  • the appointment of the rulers.

This is because I knew that the perfect State would be eyed with jealousy and was difficult to attain. The rulers must be investigated from the very beginning.

They were:

  • to be lovers of their country,
  • tried by the test of pleasures and pains,
  • never to lose their patriotism in hardships, dangers, nor at any critical moment,
  • people who always came forth pure gold tried in the refiner’s fire, and
  • to receive honours and rewards in life and after death.
Socrates

The perfect guardian must be a philosopher.

There will be few of them because the gifts which we deem essential rarely grow together. They are mostly found in shreds and patches.

Quick intelligence, memory, sagacity, cleverness, and similar qualities, do not often grow together.

  • Persons who possess them and are at the same time high-spirited and magnanimous.
  • They are not so constituted by nature as to live orderly and in a peaceful and settled manner.
  • They are driven any way by their impulses, and all solid principle goes out of them.
Socrates

On the other hand, the steadfast nature is dependable.

  • In a battle, it is impregnable to fear and is immovable.
  • But it also often goes to sleep over any intellectual toil.
  • It is equally immovable when there is anything to be learned.

Yet both qualities were necessary in those to who will receive higher education and be in command.

They will be a class which is rarely found.

  • The aspirant must not only be tested in those labours and dangers and pleasures which we mentioned before.
  • He must be exercised also in many kinds of knowledge, to see whether the soul will be able to endure the highest of all, or will faint under them, as in any other studies and exercises.