Treatise On The Virtues

The principles of all virtue are 3:

1. Knowledge

Knowledge is how we contemplate and form a judgment of things.

2. Power

Power is a certain strength of the nature from which we derive our subsistence. It gives stability to our actions.

3. Deliberate choice

Deliberate choice is certain hands of the soul by which we are impelled to, and lay hold on the objects of our choice.

The order of the soul also subsists as follows:

• One part of it is the reasoning power
• Another part is anger
• Another is desire.

The reasoning power is that which has dominion over knowledge.

Anger is that which rules over the ardent impulses of the soul.

Desire is that which willingly rules over appetite.

When these three pass into one, so as to exhibit one co-adaptation, then virtue and concord are produced in the soul.

But when they are seditious, and divulsed from each other, then vice and discord are generated in the soul.

When the reasoning power prevails over the irrational parts of the soul, then endurance and continence are produced:

• Endurance in the retention of pains
• Continence in the abstinence from pleasures.

But when the irrational parts of the soul prevail over the reasoning power, then effeminacy and incontinence are produced:

• Effeminacy in flying from pain
• Incontinence, in the being vanquished by pleasures.

Virtue and every good are generated in the whole soul when:

• the better part of the soul governs the less excellent part
• the better part consent, and are concordant with the less excellent part

Temperance is produced when the appetitive follows the reasoning part of the soul.

Fortitude is produced when the irascible part follows.

Justice is produced when reason takes place in all the parts of the soul. It separates all the vices and all the virtues of the soul from each other.

It is a certain established order of the apt conjunction of the parts of the soul, and perfect and supreme virtue.

For every good is contained in this; but the other goods of the soul cannot subsist without this. Hence justice possesses great strength both among Gods and men.

For this virtue contains the bond by which the whole and the universe are held together, and also by which Gods and men are connected.

Justice is said to be Themis among the celestial. But Dice among the terrestrial Gods and Law among men.

These assertions are indications and symbols, that justice is the supreme virtue.

Virtue is called:

• prudence when it consists in contemplating and judging.
• fortitude when it is in sustaining things of a dreadful nature
• temperance when is in restraining pleasure
• justice when it is in abstaining from gain, and from injuring our neighbours.

The arrangement of virtue according to right reason produce a tendency to the decorous as the final mark. Its divergence from right reason leads to the frustration of the decorous.

The indecorous has 2 species:

1. Excess
2. Defect

Excess is more, but deficiency is less, than is decorous.

Virtue is a certain habit of the decorous. Hence it is directly, both a summit and a medium.

Things that are decorous are both media and summits.

• They are media because they fall between excess and deficiency
• They are summits, because they do not require either addition or ablation. For they are the very things themselves which they should be.

The virtue of manners is conversant with the passions. But since pleasure and pain are the supreme passions, it means that virtue does not consist in destroying the passions of the soul, pleasure and pain, but in co-harmonizing them.

Good health is an apt mixture of the powers of the body. It consists in expelling the cold and the hot, the moist and the dry – these are appropriately mingled together as a certain symmetry.

Similarly in music, concord does not consist in expelling the sharp and the flat. But when these are co-harmonized, then concord is produced, and dissonance is exterminated.

Similarly, the hot and the cold, the moist and the dry, being harmoniously mingled together, health is produced, and disease destroyed.

But when anger, and desire are co-harmonized:

• the vices and the other passions are extirpated, and
• the virtues and manners are ingenerated.

Deliberate choice however is the greatest peculiarity of the virtue of manners.

For it is possible to use reason and power without virtue.

• But it is not possible to use deliberate choice without it, because deliberate choice indicates the dignity of manners.

Hence also, the reasoning power subduing by force anger and desire, produces continence and endurance.

Again, when the reasoning power is violently dethroned by the irrational parts, then incontinence and effeminacy are produced. Such dispositions however, of the soul as these, are half-perfect virtues, and half-perfect vices.

The reasoning power of the soul is [according to its natural subsistence] in a healthy, but the irrational parts are in a diseased condition.

Anger and desire are governed and led by the rational part of the soul, continence and endurance become virtues; but so far as this is effected by violence, and not voluntarily, they become vices. For it is necessary that virtue should perform such things as are fit, not with pain, but with pleasure.

So far as anger and desire govern the reasoning power, effeminacy and incontinence are produced, which are certain vices. But so far, as they gratify the passions with pain, knowing that they are erroneous, in consequence of the eye of the soul being sane,—so far as this is the case, they are not vices.

Hence, virtue must necessarily perform what is fit voluntarily; that which is involuntary, not being without pain and fear; and that which is voluntary, not subsisting without pleasure and delight.

By division also it will at the same time be found that this is the case.

Knowledge and perception are the province of the rational part of the soul.

Power pertains to the irrational part.

The irrational part is unable to resist pain, or vanquish pleasure.

But deliberate choice subsists in both these, viz. in the rational; and also in the irrational part.

For it consists of dianoia and appetite; of which, dianoia indeed, pertains to the rational, but appetite to the irrational part. Hence every virtue consists in a co-adaptation of the parts of the soul; and both will and deliberate choice, entirely subsist in virtue.

Universally therefore, virtue is a certain co-adaptation of the irrational parts of the soul to the rational part.

Virtue however, is produced through pleasure and pain receiving the boundary of that which is fit.

For true virtue is nothing else than the habit of that which is fit. But the fit, or the decorous, is that which ought to be; and the unfit, or indecorous, is that which should not to be.

There are 2 kinds of indecorous:

1. Excess – this is more than is fit
2. Defect – this is less than is fit

The fit is that which should be.

• It is both a summit and a middle.
• It is a summit because it neither requires ablation, nor addition
• It is a middle because it subsists between excess and defect.

The fit and the unfit are to each other as the equal and the unequal that which is arranged, and that which is without arrangement.

Both the two former and the two latter are finite and infinite.[70]

On this account, the parts of the unequal are referred to the middle, but not to each other. For the angle is called obtuse which is greater than a right angle; but that is called acute, which is less than a right angle.

The right line also [in a circle] is greater, which surpasses that which is drawn from the center. The day is longer which exceeds that of the equinox.

Diseases, likewise, of the body are generated, through the body becoming more hot or more cold [than is proper]. For that which is more hot [than is fit] exceeds moderation; and that which is more cold [than is fit] is below mediocrity.

The soul have this disposition and analogy.

Audacity is an excess of the decorous in the endurance of things of a dreadful nature.

But timidity is a deficiency of the, decorous. And prodigality is an excess of what is fit in the expenditure of money; but illiberality is a deficiency in this.

Rage is an excess of the decorous in the impulse of the irascible part of the soul; but insensibility is a deficiency of this.

The same reasoning likewise applies to the opposition of the other dispositions of the soul.

Virtue is a habit of the decorous and a medium of the passions. It should neither be wholly impassive, nor immoderately passive.

Impassivity causes the soul to be unimpelled, and to be without an enthusiastic tendency to the beautiful in conduct.

But immoderate passivity causes it to be full of perturbation, and inconsiderate.

It is necessary that passion should so present itself to the view, in virtue, as shadow and outline in a picture.

For the animated and the delicate, and that which imitates the truth, in conjunction with goodness of colors, are especially effected in a picture through these [i. e. through shadow and outline].

The passions of the soul are animated by the natural incitation and enthusiasm of virtue.

Virtue is generated from the passions, and when generated, again subsists together with them; just as that which is well harmonized consists of the sharp and the flat, that which is well mingled consists of the hot and the cold, and that which is in equilibrium derives its equality of weight from the heavy and the light.

It is not therefore necessary to take away the passions of the soul; for neither would this be profitable; but it is requisite that they should be co-harmonized with the rational part, in conjunction with fitness and mediocrity.