The Huygens Aether (2nd Element) is Not the Cartesian Aether (5th Element)

Author avatar
by Juan Apr 13, 2022
5 min read 1028 words
Table of Contents

Before Newtonian Physics was created, the mainstream Physics was from Descartes who used a 5 Element paradigm which was derived from the Physics of Aristotle and Timaeus. This was consistent with the 5 Elements model of Hinduism and Taoism.

This model had 5 Elements, 3 of which are known by Physics as the Standard Model

Element Physics Equivalent
Aether Pseudo science
Air Spacetime
Fire Electromagnetism
Water Weak Force
Earth or Matter Strong Force

The Subjectivity of the Aether

This model is confusing for materialists because it makes the aether as the supreme Element and matter or mass as the lowest and most inferior.

We define the aether as the substance of ideas, feelings, and the abstract minds that have those ideas and feelings.

This is why the aether is the core ingredient in quantum mechanics which creates superposition and decoherence – the observing mind is part of the system being tested!

This is why quantum mechanics is spooky to materialist physicists who see matter as the highest Element, when in fact it is the lowest and crudest.

The aether serves as the foundation of the abstract sciences such as psychology, politics, economics, sociology, just as matter and energy serve the foundation of Physics and Engineering.

The life sciences such as biology, medicine, and agriculture are in between both.

Einstein Debunking the Aether

Materialists hate subjectivity so much that they do everything that they can to discredit the subjective aether. This is exactly what Einstein did when he interpreted the Michelson-Morley experiment in favor of energy, while denouncing the abstract mind (soul, feelings).

These two postulates of Relativity suffice for a simple and consistent theory of the electrodynamics of moving bodies based on Maxwell’s theory for stationary bodies.

The introduction of a “luminiferous ether” is superfluous. There is no need for an “absolutely stationary space” that has special properties.

Einstein
Einstein On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies

Einstein created Relativity by simply ignoring the aether that would later facilitate quantum mechanics. This is why he was against quantum mechanics in his paper “Is the Quantum—Mechanical Reality Complete?”.

The consistent success of quantum mechanics and the consistent failure of theories derived from General Relativity such as String Theory, Loop Quantum Gravity, Supersymmetry, Big Bang, Wormholes, White Holes, etc show that Nature is quantum mechanical, and not Einstein-Relativistic.

Einstein only really doubled down on the non existence of the aether, called the ‘aether drag’, when he had to formalize General Relativity.

There is no such thing as a “specially favoured” (unique) coordinate system that allows the æther-idea. Hence, there can be no æther-drift nor any experiment with which to demonstrate it.

Einstein
Einstein Relativity

The Huygens Ether, Frensel Ether, and Descartes Aether are Different

Einstein’s statement shows the confusion of physicists on the aether idea.

Aether Superphysics Equivalent
Descartes Aether
Huygens Pure Spacetime via Light
Fresnel Spacetime in Material Layer via Light
Stokes Spacetime in Material Layer via Matter
Maxwell Spacetime in Radiant Layer via Light
Helmholtz and Kelvin Aetherspace in Material Layer via Heat

As you can see there were many aether ideas. The modern luminiferous aether theory is from Fresnel who described light moving in a crystal, making it variant and directional.

The intensity of light is proportional to the square of the speeds of the particles. The intensity of vibration, on the other hand, is the speed of an ether particle during its oscillation.

Fresnel
Fresnel Memoir On The Diffraction Of Light, Section 2

However, the Michelson-Morley experiment proved that the light was invariant. Therefore, it debunked the variant Fresnel ether.

To save the Fresnel ether theory, Lorentz created the concept of length contraction which allowed the shapes of material bodies to vary in accordance with the invariance of space.

If one assumes the theory of Fresnel, then we can learn something about the change of dimensions.

Hendrik Lorentz
Hendrik Lorentz

The correctness of length contraction proves that:

  • the 2nd Element (space particles) are invariant because there is no Void in Nature
  • the 3rd Element (matter) is variant because it is different from space

This is totally different from the aether of Huygens which is now called the fabric of spacetime. Note that even this fabric is different from the original aether of Descartes.

We bridge the Huygens aether with the Descares aether through the concept of the aetherspace.

The Problem Began with Huygens, Made Worse by Fresnel

The whole problem began when Huygens wrongly renamed the pure 2nd Element as Ethereal matter. This created confusion with the pure aether as the 5th Element.

The movement of light coming from the luminous body is propagated through what I call “Ethereal matter”. It is not the same that serves for the propagation of sound.

Blank
Huygens Treatise On Light
Huygens aether
The Huygens aether is actually the 2nd Element of Descartes or spacetime, different from the pure aether (what we call the 5th Element)
Superphysics Note
In The World, Descartes actually calls all the 3 Elements as aether. The pure aether is called substance. This is because all Cartesian particles are virtual. But this is confusing to modern Physics which believes that all particles are real and only some are virtual. So to strike a compromise, we put the virtual aether as the 5th Element. The 2nd Element is also virtual but not totally aethereal as we can clearly see the space around us (the aetherspace and timespace are aethereal)

The 2nd Element, as empty space, propagates light, while the 3rd Element, as air or matter, propagates sound.

Huygens aether
The misnaming of Huygens on the 2nd Element created the confusion about the properties of space and the aether

Space-Time is Not Material

The final error of Physics is to think that the either the aether or the 2nd Element are material in nature.

In reality, they are metaphysical because they are above electromagnetism (1st Element). They can only be detected by the mind through its ideas and feelings of space and time.

This makes Physics perpetually impotent in discovering their properties. This is why our proposed Superphysics has both physics and metaphysics combined.

This will allow us to discover their properties in order to develop technologies that defy space and time, such as levitation, teleportation, and time travel.

Send us your comments!